The takeaway
Labor is used in production, and measuring the costs of that labor is important for business decisionmaking. There are several ways to measure these costs, and it’s important to know their differences.
Three forms of labor cost data
To understand the changes in the cost of labor, researchers commonly use one of three time series: hourly wages, the employment cost index, and unit labor cost.
Average hourly wage of workers is the first and most obvious, shown by the solid blue line in our FRED graph above. It’s the percent change from a year ago of average hourly earnings for all private employees. The line generally hovers around 2.5%, but it sharply increased in early 2020 at the time of the COVID-19 recession. In recent quarters, the line has been between 3.5% and 4%.
This series has two drawbacks. First, it doesn’t account for compositional changes that occur when the economy slows. Research from the St. Louis Fed showed that low-wage workers have been more likely to lose their jobs than high-wage workers; average hourly earnings drastically shifts up as the economy loses lower-wage workers. Second, average hourly earnings doesn’t consider other employment benefits such as healthcare, pensions, and bonuses.
The Employment Cost Index (ECI) doesn’t have these drawbacks. It’s the change in hourly labor cost to employers, shown by the solid green line in our FRED graph. According to the BLS, “The ECI uses a fixed ‘basket’ of labor to produce a pure cost change, free from the effects of workers moving between occupations and industries.” By including both wages and benefits in its calculation, the ECI gives us a better picture of total compensation as well. During the COVID-19 recession, the ECI trends downward, as it does not suffer from the compositional changes noted previously.
Unit labor cost (ULC) is our third measure, shown by the dashed orange line. It measures the ratio of hourly compensation to labor productivity, capturing how much it costs employers to produce a unit of output. Like the ECI, it includes both wages and benefits. It also accounts for productivity changes: When workers produce more output per hour, labor costs effectively decline. In the graph, we see ULC is more variable over time than the other two measures. In recent quarters, ULC growth has fallen below the other measures because of solid labor productivity growth.
How this graph was created: Search FRED for and select “Average Hourly Earnings of All Employees, Total Private.” Click “Edit Graph,” adjust units to “Percent Change from Year Ago,” and change frequency to “Quarterly.” Click “Add Line,” search for “Employment Cost Index: Total compensation,” and select the private industry series. Click “Add Line” again and search for “Unit Labor Costs for All Workers” in the nonfarm business sector. Change the start date of the graph to January 2002. Click “Format” to change line styles: Line 2 “solid,” Line 3 “dash,” and all line widths 2.
Suggested by Serdar Birinci and Gus Gerlach.