There’s no direct way to measure the market power of employees or employers, but some indicators can provide clues. One such indicator is the ratio of quits to layoffs, shown in the FRED graph above.
When employees feel they have good bargaining chips, they’re more like to quit a job, generally for a better one. In this situation, employers are less likely to lay off their workers: (i) because their best workers may already be leaving and (ii) because new workers might bargain for better conditions. So, when employees have more market power, quits should be higher and layoffs should be lower, which means this ratio should be high.
In the opposite situation (during a recession, for example), fewer employees quit because there are fewer opportunities. They feel their bargaining power is lower, and the quits-to-layoffs ratio is lower.
The recent data in the graph reveal that employees enjoyed historic levels of market power during the pandemic, but that has recently eroded to more typical levels. This observation is consistent with the increasingly successful return-to-work mandates across the economy, whereby employers have managed to impose more and more of their conditions in the workplace.
How this graph was created: In FRED, search for and select the series for “quits.” In the “Edit Graph” panel, add the second series by searching for and selecting “layoffs.” Apply formula a/b.
Suggested by Christian Zimmermann.