Federal Reserve Economic Data

The FRED® Blog

Slow…labor…productivity…growth

How does productivity affect our future?

Since the beginning of 2011, growth in real output in the nonfarm business sector has been slow, averaging just 2.7% percent. And most of the economic growth has been driven by increases in labor inputs and not by increases in labor productivity. The graph shows real output growth (green line) decomposed into growth in labor input (red line) and growth in labor productivity (blue line), where productivity is measured as real output per hour. Given that the output growth rates are only slightly different from—either a little above or a little below—growth in hours, the majority of growth in output has come from increases in hours instead of increases in labor productivity. Labor productivity growth averaged 0.7% over this period, accounting for just 27% percent of real GDP growth.

Labor productivity growth amounts to the average growth of how much goods and services each individual can produce and, thus, is the driving force behind increases in the standard of living. More importantly, a small difference in labor productivity growth leads to a dramatic difference in the standard of living over the long run. For example, if labor productivity growth held steady at 2%, which is the rate seen in the expansion from 2001 to 2007, the living standard would double in 35 years. If labor productivity continues to grow at 0.7%, it would take 99 years to double the standard of living.

How this graph was created: After searching for “nonfarm business sector,” select “Index 2009=100” for the three series and click on “Add to Graph.” Then go to the “Edit Graph” section and select “Percent Change from Year Ago” under “Units.” Finally, click on “Copy to all” and change the starting date to “2011-01-01.”

Suggested by Yili Chien and Paul Morris.

View on FRED, series used in this post: HOANBS, OPHNFB, OUTNFB

The economics of greeting cards

Can Valentine's Day dashes to the store help the industry?

Tomorrow is Valentine’s Day, a great opportunity to spread some love…of economics…and study the greeting card industry. A search for greeting cards yields 90 results! One of the more interesting is shown in the graph. Unfortunately, we have only annual data; a higher frequency could have helped us see how much the industry depends specifically on Valentine’s Day. But we can see that the revenue of this industry appears to be trending down. So, is the reason for the decline the rise of the Internet and mobile apps? Maybe. FRED data can’t reveal all the mysteries of the universe, so we leave it to the reader to explore. Yours truly, FRED.

How this graph was created: As mentioned, a search for “greeting cards” yields quite a few results. Click on the series you want to graph.

Suggested by Christian Zimmermann.

View on FRED, series used in this post: REVEF511191ALLEST

Can businesses get loans these days?

A look at the state of commercial lending by banks

Businesses often need money and one way they get it is through commercial loans from banks. We gauge this environment by graphing the total mass of loans banks have made to commercial entities. Of course, the fact that the current mass of loans is the highest it’s ever been is hardly surprising: The economy is growing and loan levels aren’t adjusted for inflation, so this measure is bound to keep increasing. For this reason, we’ll deflate this indicator with a proxy for the size of the economy: nominal GDP (i.e., not real GDP).

Now we have a better way to compare commercial lending conditions over time. Things are still looking rather good right now, but consider these two caveats: 1. Businesses have other ways to finance—say, through private loans or issuing bonds or stock in equity markets. These options may change over time, which probably explains why there was an upward trend in the early decades, when this sort of financing was building up. 2. This reported loan mass shows only the results of supply and demand, but not how difficult it is to get a loan (actual supply) or how much businesses want these loans (actual demand).

To evaluate loan supply conditions, the Federal Reserve conducts a survey of loan officers, asking them whether they tightened loans conditions and for whom. The graph below shows this, with higher values indicating tighter lending conditions. It’s very clear how recessions have led bank officers to be more careful with their lending. But right now, conditions seem to be pretty good.

How these graphs were created: Top graph: Search for “commercial loans.” Middle graph: First, use the top graph. Then go to the “Edit Graph” panel to add “GDP” to the first line, making sure to use the nominal measure. Then apply formula a/b. Bottom graph: Start afresh and search for “loan standards”; select the two series you want and click on “Add to Graph.”

Suggested by Christian Zimmermann.

View on FRED, series used in this post: BUSLOANS, DRTSCILM, DRTSCIS, GDP


Back to Top